The owner tampered with the entrance door and affected the neighbor\’s access. Court: Doors opened from the outside should not hinder public transportation and the opening of adjacent doors and should be restored to their original state.

The owner arbitrarily widened and increased the height of the entrance door from inside to outside. , affecting the traffic of the neighbor\’s family. Recently, the Intermediate People\’s Court of Hefei City, Anhui Province issued a second-instance judgment on this neighboring rights dispute case, upholding the first-instance judgment of the Baohe District People\’s Court of Hefei City and ordering the defendant Li to restore the entrance door to its original state.

Liu and Li separated in 2010 I bought 5 houses on the 6th floor in a community in Hefei City and live next to each other. In September 2023, Li failed to report to the community property company, and without Liu\’s consent, he widened and increased the height of his entrance door, and at the same time changed the entrance door from inward opening to outward opening.

Because the two houses are adjacent, Li When the renovated entrance door was fully open, it blocked the exit of Liu\’s home. Liu\’s family members communicated and tried to dissuade Li\’s family members to no avail. Later, Liu reported the situation to the property management company and the community committee. He admitted that there were young children and elderly people at home, and the safety and fire hazards were greater after the door was blocked. At the end of September of the same year, the property management company sent a rectification letter to Li, requiring him to rectify the entrance door as soon as possible, but Li ignored it. Afterwards, the neighborhood committee and the property management company organized and coordinated many times to no avail. Liu then brought a lawsuit to the court, requesting that the defendant Li be ordered to immediately stop the infringement of unauthorized modification of the door that caused damage to himself, restore the size of the entrance door to the size before the modification, and change it back to the inside opening, and at the same time bear the consequences of the adjustment caused by his rights protection. filing fees and litigation fees.

Article 188 stipulates that neighboring rights holders of real estate shall correctly handle neighboring relations in accordance with the principles of conducive to production, convenient life, solidarity and mutual assistance, fairness and reasonableness. Article 272 stipulates that owners have the right to possess, use, benefit from and dispose of the exclusive parts of their buildings. The owner shall not endanger the safety of the building or damage the legitimate rights and interests of other owners when exercising their rights. Article 5.8.5 of the Ministry of Construction\’s \”Residential Design Code\” (GB50096-2011) stipulates that outward-opening doors should not hinder public transportation and the opening of adjacent doors. In this case, when Li\’s modified entrance door was fully open, it almost completely blocked the entrance door of Liu\’s family, and restricted the normal access of Liu\’s family.Intrusion has an impact and also creates certain safety hazards.

In summary, the court held that Li Anyone who changes the direction or size of the entrance door without authorization is inappropriate and should be restored to its original state. The plaintiff, despite the failure of multi-party coordination, incurred reasonable expenditures in obtaining the defendant\’s identity information for the purpose of litigation, and has provided evidence, which should be supported.

Therefore, the court of first instance ruled that the defendant Li will enter prison The door of the household was restored to its original state, the plaintiff Liu was paid the shift fee, and the litigation costs were borne. Li was dissatisfied and appealed. After hearing the case, the Hefei Intermediate People\’s Court rejected the appeal and upheld the original judgment.

Judge’s reminder

Being kind and kind to neighbors is a traditional virtue of the Chinese nation. When dealing with neighbors, we must abide by public ethics. Everyone has the right to pursue a comfortable life, but the exercise of rights also has boundaries. The boundaries of rights should not be exceeded at will, and the legitimate rights and interests of others should not be harmed. Neighbors should carry forward the traditional virtues of the Chinese nation in their daily lives, set a good example for their children, and create a good and harmonious family tradition.

Source: China Court Network

Reporter: Zhou Ruiping

Correspondent :Yu Shengyun

本站内容及图片来自网络,版权归原作者所有,内容仅供读者参考,不承担相关法律责任,如有侵犯请联系我们:609448834

Like (0)
华夏门网的头像华夏门网
Previous 2025年1月3日
Next 2025年1月3日

相关推荐

  • 家居小知识:入户门应该怎么选?看完这篇文章就知道了

    入户门,是回家的第一道门,也是保证室内隐私和安全的第一道重要枷锁,因此给家装一道安全、防盗、美观的优质门至关重要。那么,你知道入户门主要有哪些类型吗?不同材质的门都有哪些优缺点?在装修房子的时候选哪些门比较好呢?今天,我们请金空间的温创建设计师来分享几道选门的小知识,希望能为您的爱家保驾护航。 看完这篇文章,相信您已经知道怎么选入户门了吧!如果您还想了解更多…

    入户门 2023年12月19日
    280
  • In 2023, sales volume in the home door market will decline by 11.7% year-on-year.

    Overview of the entry door market With the improvement of people\’s awareness of home security and the advancement of urbanization, the demand for home door market continues …

    入户门 2025年1月8日
    20
  • 入户门安装全攻略:6大要点,让你的新家更安全!

    亲们,拿到新房后,是不是迫不及待地想要更换入户门呢?但是,入户门的安装可不是一件简单的事哦!为了确保安全、避免后续麻烦,这6大要点你必须知道! 1️、选对时间,事半功倍 更换入户门的最佳时机是在房屋拆改之后、墙地面处理之前。这样不仅可以避免装修过程中对门造成损坏,还能确保门的安装更加牢固。 2️、尺寸,至关重要! 门的尺寸一定要精确!建议找专业师傅上门测量,…

    入户门 2024年2月27日
    200
  • 装了两套房,才明白换入户门的必要性,除了防盗还要考虑这4点

    装了两套房,才明白换入户门的必要性,除了防盗还要考虑这4点! 装修房子,需不需要更换入户门,是很多朋友都非常关心的问题。 先来说说新房,交房时开发商已经做了入户门,一般是防火防盗门,但是实际标准会比较低,也就是刚刚达标的水平。毕竟开发商买房子,都会控制成本,入户门也不会给你装特别好的。是否换门,要根据装修预算和实际需求来综合考虑。 再来说说老房,任何设施都是…

    入户门 2023年9月22日
    210
  • 入户门内开?外开?哪个好

    入户门是内开外开的学问 《建筑设计防火规范》第6.1.3条中明确规定“高层居住建筑的户门不应直接开向前室,当确有困难时,部分开向前室的户门均就为乙级防火门”。 此系为保障高层建筑在发生火灾时居民能及时有效逃离火灾现场,高层和小高层建筑的入户门应遵循朝人群疏散方向开启,即入户门外开。 因为如果发生火灾,慌乱的人群习惯向外冲,门朝外开符合人群流动方向和应急情况下…

    入户门 2023年11月7日
    300

联系我们

400-800-8888

在线咨询: QQ交谈

邮件:[email protected]

工作时间:周一至周五,9:30-18:30,节假日休息

关注微信